Join the club for FREE to access the whole archive and other member benefits.

What exactly is so bad about dying?

Travis Timmerman explores the fundamental nature of death in depth

In this episode of Levity, philosopher Dr. Travis Timmerman, an associate professor at Seton Hall University, explores the philosophical and emotional terrain of death, challenging conventional assumptions and asking: Is death truly bad for us, and if so, why?

Key Points:

Death may seem universally tragic, but its badness isn’t as obvious as it feels. Dr. Timmerman unpacks the ethical, personal, and logical reasons we fear and resent death—and why we might rethink them.

  • What Makes Death Bad (If It Is): Dr. Timmerman explains that death isn’t bad in itself but is typically considered bad because it deprives us of future experiences we would have valued.
  • The Problem of Non-Existence: He discusses the "deprivation account" of death, arguing that the harm of death lies in what it prevents us from experiencing, even though we aren’t aware of our own non-existence.
  • Can You Be Harmed by What You Don't Feel?: The conversation tackles the philosophical challenge of whether something can be bad for someone if they never feel it—like being dead.
  • Death and Timing: The badness of death depends on when it happens; dying young is often seen as worse because of the greater loss of potential life.
  • Immortality Isn’t the Answer (Necessarily): Contrary to intuition, Timmerman notes that living forever may not be ideal—it could lead to stagnation, boredom, or the loss of identity over time.
  • Should We Fear Death?: Fear of death is natural, but Timmerman suggests it may be philosophically irrational if death is simply the end of experience.
  • Death and Ethical Decision-Making: The episode explores how our views on death affect moral decisions in areas like euthanasia, life extension, and healthcare priorities.
  • Personal Reflections and Public Relevance: Dr. Timmerman shares his personal approach to the fear of death and how confronting these questions can lead to a more meaningful life.

Visit website: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=emLPQ1X04pE

See also

LEVITY Podcast

Ageing Science and radical life extension podcast with Peter Ottsjö and Ingemar Patrick Linden

Details last updated 05-Jun-2025

Mentioned in this Resource

Travis Timmerman

Associate Professor of Philosophy at Seton Hall University